SORT BY:

LIST ORDER
THREAD
AUTHOR
SUBJECT


SEARCH

IPS HOME


    [Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

    Re: Performance of iSCSI, FCIP and iFCP




    Could an FCIP expert reply to the technical question that Victor raised in this message?

    thanks
    -franco

    At 02:47 PM 1/10/01, Firoiu, Victor [BL60:470-M:EXCH] wrote:

    Vi,

    thanks for your comments.  Indeed, there is no such limitation in the
    FCIP ID.  But there is no consideration for multiple TCP connections
    either.  What specifically governs the use of TCP flow A as opposed to
    TCP flow B when two FCIP gateways are communicating?

    As we've seen in our examples, the performance is significantly
    (quadratically) impacted by the choice of number of TCP connections.
    Fine-grain control over multiple TCP connections thus becomes
    mandatory between any two FC islands of non-trivial size.  The most
    natural way to multiplex storage connections (FC or SCSI) on multiple
    TCP connections is to have one or a few TCP connections per storage
    connection, that is, to use storage connection awareness for assigning
    TCP connections to storage connections (iSCSI, iFCP).

    Surely, it is possible to multiplex storage connections into TCP
    connections without any knowledge of the identity of storage
    connections.  But this brings up issues including load balancing,
    interdependency between storage connections sharing TCP connections,
    managing storage connections that are striped across TCP connections
    (as thoroughly discussed within the iSCSI community).  It seems that
    the iSCSI and iFCP solution of assigning one (or a few) TCP
    connection(s) for each storage connections has many practical and
    performance merits that needs a special attention in FCIP also.

    Again, any comments are very welcome.

    Victor Firoiu
    -----
    Content Internetworking Lab, Technology Center
    Nortel Networks, Inc.
    600 Technology ParkBillerica, MA 01821 USA

    Vi Chau wrote:
    >
    > Hi,
    >
    >    There is nothing in the FCIP I-D that limits the
    > tunnel between the SAN islands to one TCP connection. The
    > FCIP gateways can open as many TCP connections as it can
    > support to reach any number of destination gateways.
    >
    > Vi Chau
    > Gadzoox Networks, Inc.
    > 16241 Laguna Canyon Road, Suite 100
    > Irvine, CA 92618-3611
    > 949-789-4639
    >


Home

Last updated: Tue Sep 04 01:05:52 2001
6315 messages in chronological order