SORT BY:

LIST ORDER
THREAD
AUTHOR
SUBJECT


SEARCH

IPS HOME


    [Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

    iscsi: Text keys



    Julian,
    
    Some comments on the text keys defined in Appendix E.
    
    thanks,
    -Sandeep
    
    1) There are several text keys which have been specified
       with Use=ALL.  Such keys can be negotiated during 
       full-feature phase, which raises interesting questions
       about their effect on currently outstanding tasks.
    
       For example,
       a) maxOutstandingR2T : what is the effect on currently
          outstanding R2Ts ?
       b) LoginLogoutMaxTime : how does it affect connections
    	  which just got dropped and need to be recovered ?
       c) DataPDULength : effect on data PDUs in flight.
    
       Similar questions need to be answered for practically
       all the keys which have this behaviour.  For the sake of 
       simplicity, it may be better to forbid such usage and 
       allow these keys to be only negotiated in the connection 
       or session login phase.
    
    2) The paragraph on TargetAddress seems to indicate that one 
       or more text responses could be sent to satisfy a SendTargets 
       command.  
    	 "If the list cant be delivered as a single text
    	 response PDU, ..several text response PDUs can
    	 be sent..logical merge of the individual lists".
       
       How does the initiator know more than one TextResponse PDUs 
       are expected for that TextCommand PDU ?  If the final bit is 
       to be used, does it imply that the initiator should keep 
       sending the sendTargets TextCommand with f=1 until it 
       receives the last TextResponse PDU ?
    
       Could you please clarify...
    
    3) SendTargets again.  The ordering within the text response 
       currently is implied and needs to be specified so that 
       the initiator can correlate the target alias with the 
       target addresses.  
    
       Something along these lines may help
    	"The order within a text response should be
    	  (targetName, targetAlias(if any), list of addresses)"
    
    4) The section on InitiatorName seems to imply that the 
       target can also propose the value for this key ??
       I presume this is a typo.
    	 See "Who: Initiator and Target"
    
    


Home

Last updated: Tue Sep 04 01:04:48 2001
6315 messages in chronological order